Whether you’re buying your first property, looking to sell a beloved family home, or relocating to a new neighborhood in the city, working with the right real estate agent makes all the difference. In a competitive and ever-changing market like Columbus, it’s essential to have a skilled advocate by your side. Someone who understands the details, data, and history behind each transaction, and who can help you opt for the best outcome every step of the way.
Top Columbus Realtors don’t just know the fees or paperwork; they know the character and trends of neighborhoods like German Village, Short North, Bexley, and Upper Arlington. Many Realtors in Columbus Ohio even specialize in certain areas or property types, from modern condos downtown to luxury real estate in suburban enclaves.
As you begin your search, you’ll want to join forces with a Columbus real estate agency that knows the ins and outs of the local landscape and is backed by the Columbus Board of Realtors. This ensures your real estate agent is licensed, trained, and up to date with the latest market shifts and legal standards.
In this blog, we’ll highlight some of the most respected Columbus Realtors, share tips on choosing the right agent for your goals, and guide you through how to understand what makes an agent stand out in this dynamic city.
Table of Contents
Who Are the Top Columbus Real Estate Agents?
When it comes to making one of the biggest financial decisions of your life, whether it’s buying or selling a home, you want to work with someone you can trust. The right real estate agent will do more than just show properties or handle paperwork. They’ll act as your advocate, helping you navigate the market, negotiate a strong deal, and simplify every step of the process. But with so many Columbus Realtors to choose from, how do you know which one is the best fit?
The answer lies in doing your homework. But that’s where we come in. We’ve done the search for you, compiling a list of the top-performing agents and teams based on experience, client satisfaction, local knowledge, and range of services. These experts know how to guide clients through fluctuating fees, competitive listings, and fast-paced decision-making, ensuring your home journey is as smooth as possible.
Here are a few of the top Columbus Realtors who are standing out in today’s dynamic market.
#1 Kyle Edwards
View this post on Instagram
When it comes to Columbus Realtors, Kyle Edwards is the best. Edwards is a real estate agent with The Brokerage House and is not only one of the best in the city, but in the whole state. He is ranked 7th in the state of Ohio by RealTrends and specializes in property in Central Ohio. In 2024, he had a sales volume of $37.24 million.
#2 Jeff Mahler
Thousands of recommendations list Jeff Mahler as one of the best Columbus Realtors. Jeff was born and raised in Columbus and strives to provide residents with the best services in town. As one of the best Realtors in Columbus Ohio, Jeff is ranked in the top 1% of Realtors in Ohio and in the top 1.5% of Realtors in the Nation.
#3 Brad Shields
One of the top Columbus realtors, Brad Shields, is a real estate agent with Redfin and has been serving the area for several years. Whether you need to buy or sell a property, join Brad Shields for a seamless process. When you choose Brad, you’ll gain a real estate agent who knows the area well and can help you navigate the market with ease. He has over 160 total deals and a sales volume of $67 million.
#4 Regan Lowe
Regan Lowe is one of the best Columbus realtors and will work hard to help you find a home that’s right for you. Regan works under The Brokerage House and has been recognized by RealTrends as one of the top 1.5% agents in the United States. In 2024, she had a sales volume of $20.11 million.
#5 Emily Groza Yoko
View this post on Instagram
Ranked in the top 1% of Columbus Realtors, Emily Groza Yoko is a fantastic, experienced Columbus real estate agent. As one of six Founding Agents of The Brokerage House, Emily was born in Columbus, Ohio, and began working in real estate in 2017.
#6 Benjamin Goodman
If you’re searching for the best realtors in Columbus Ohio, then look no further than Benjamin Goodman. Ben Goodman is a lifelong resident of the city, a graduate of Ohio University, and has been a licensed Realtor for over 10 years. He currently lives in Upper Arlington, but is familiar with all niche markets within Columbus.
#7 Mary Campbell Staebler
Mary Campbell Staebler is one of the best Columbus Realtors and has been serving the area for decades. Mary has been a resident of Columbus for over 30 years and knows the city like the back of her hand. She specializes in staging, marketing, and promoting listings and has made over 550 sales. From 2021 to 2024, she was recognized in the top 1%-2% of agents worldwide.
#8 Jim Bevins
Working with RE/MAX, Jim Bevins is a top-rated real estate agent who serves all of Columbus and the surrounding communities. As one of the most experienced Columbus Realtors, Jim has over two decades of experience renovating homes as a side passion, and can provide tips for preparing a home sale, including repairs and staging.
#9 Pam Meige
Pam Meige is one of the best Columbus Realtors in the city, with over 30 years of experience. As a lifelong resident of Columbus, Pam is familiar with all of the wonderful Columbus neighborhoods and completed her real estate training with Hondros College. In 2024, she had 28.3 transaction sides and $15.19 million in sales volume.
#10 Dewayne Yates
View this post on Instagram
As one of the best Columbus realtors, Dewayne Yates works with Coldwell Banker Realty and is the team lead of the Dewayne Yates Team. Yates has been in the business since 2018 and has quickly achieved a Top Producer status in just a few years. He has also been featured on HGTV for House Hunts and has won multiple awards for his real estate expertise. In 2024, Dewayne had over $14 million in sales volume.
What Are the Top Real Estate Teams in Columbus Ohio?
View this post on Instagram
If you’re on the search for a real estate agent in the city, then you may also want to look for a full team of Columbus realtors. Real estate teams are real estate companies in Columbus Ohio that are made up of two or more Realtors in Columbus Ohio who help each other out with resources.
When you use these real estate agencies in Columbus Ohio, you greatly benefit as a customer. Because these teams are made up of multiple Realtors in Columbus Ohio, you’ll have more resources than ever available to you.
Here are a few of the best real estate teams in Columbus Ohio.
1. Columbus House Team
The team of Columbus Realtors at the Columbus House Team works under eXp Realty and works with both buyers and sellers in the Columbus area. They specialize in Columbus luxury homes and do a lot of their work in the Pickerington and Dublin neighborhoods. In 2024, they had a sales volume of $130.83 million and 383 transaction sides.
2. The Kendle Team
With a sales volume of $36.10 million in 2024, The Kendle Team works under RE/MAX and knows the Central Ohio area well. They are members of the Columbus Board of Realtors and have Emmy award-winning aerial photography and media support.
3. Ritchie Realty Group
Ritchie Realty Group is a team of Columbus Realtors with over 8,000 agents on their team. They’ve sold over $800 million in real estate, over 2,550 homes, and have over 60 years of experience.
4. The Powell Buehler Group
When searching for the best team of Columbus Realtors, look no further than The Powell Buehler Group. This team operates under Coldwell Banker Realty and had $55.23 million in sales volume in 2024.
5. Core Realty Collection
Core Realty Collection has been serving the area since 2006 and is led by founder Misty Linn. In 2024, they had 127 transaction sides and over $41 million in sales volume.
What Are the Best Brokerages in Columbus?
A real estate brokerage is a firm where a team of Columbus Realtors works. Within this agency, you’ll find Realtors in Columbus Ohio, brokers, and brokerages all working together to help buyers navigate the market. Most of the time, a Columbus real estate agent working at a brokerage is an entry-level professional who is looking to gain experience. They rely on brokers to help them throughout the process, and give up a percentage of their commission in return for resources from the brokerage.
Here are a few of the top brokerages in Columbus Ohio.
|
Top Columbus Realtors Top Brokerages by Sales Volume |
||||
| Brokerage | State Rank | Location | Transaction Sides | Sales Volume |
| Keller Williams Consultants Realty | 2 | Dublin, Ohio | 4,766 | $1.68 billion |
| Keller Williams Capital Partners Realty | 12 | Worthington, Ohio | 2,127.3 | $805.15 million |
| Keller Williams Greater Columbus Realty | 14 | Columbus, Ohio | 1,741.1 | $628.06 million |
| Keller Williams Classic Properties Realty | 16 | Upper Arlington, Ohio | 1,247 | $537.44 million |
| NextHome Experience | N/A | Worthington, Ohio | 910 | $309.64 million |
| RE/MAX Partners | N/A | Columbus, Ohio | 702 | $304.45 million |
| RE/MAX Revealty | N/A | Columbus, Ohio | 900 | $287.79 million |
| RE/MAX One | N/A | Pickerington, Ohio | 706.5 | $246.51 million |
What Are the Largest Columbus Real Estate Brokerages?
View this post on Instagram
If you’re looking for a large team of Columbus Realtors rather than a single real estate agent, then you may want to choose a large brokerage. Working with real estate brokerages in Columbus Ohio ensures you always have someone to contact. These are the largest real estate brokerages in Columbus Ohio.
- eXp Realty: eXp Realty is home to thousands of Columbus realtors, specializing in luxury homes throughout Franklin County.
- JMG: JMG is a family-owned real estate company with expertise in residential homes, new homes, condos, and vacant land.
- LPT Realty: With over 10,000 agents in 19 different states, LPT Realty is one of the largest teams of Columbus realtors around.
- Keller Williams Greater Columbus Realty: If you need a real estate agent in Columbus, Keller Williams Greater Columbus Realty is your best bet.
- Compass: With thousands of Columbus Realtors, Compass is a great choice when looking for real estate experts in Columbus.
FAQs About Columbus Realtors
Who Is the Top Realtor in Columbus Ohio?
Out of all of the Columbus realtors, Kyle Edwards is the best-performing agent in the city.
How Much Do Columbus Realtors Make?
Most Columbus realtors take around 5% to 6% of the total sale price.
Is The Columbus OH Real Estate Market Picking Up?
The Columbus real estate market has held pretty steady over the past year. According to Redfin, Columbus home prices are only up 0.1% compared to last year, with a median home price of $290,350. It’s still a good idea to hire a Columbus real estate agent to help you navigate the market, though.
Should I Hire a Columbus Realtor?
Absolutely! Columbus Realtors can help you navigate everything from negotiations to closing strategies.
Are You Ready to Find Your New Home in Columbus?
Now that you know all of the best realtors in Columbus Ohio, it’s time to make your move! Any one of these Columbus realtors would be a valuable asset in your relocation. Once you’re ready to make your move, give the team at Krupp Moving & Storage a call. We’ll help you handle everything on the moving front so you can focus on settling into your new home.
To get started with a free quote, give our Columbus movers a call at (614) 892-9046.
